Miley Cyrus – Wrecking Ball
So, as of today, there are approximately 16 billion search results that will come up when you type “Miley Cyrus” into any search engine (I’m making this number up but I’m pretty sure it’s accurate), and I’m here to add another! Woohoo!
Now, I’m not a Miley fan. Right off the bat, I can tell you that I only enjoyed watching Hannah Montana the TV series, I didn’t like the movie all that much and haven’t really followed her career with any vested interest since. However, her recent choices have become so embroiled in the media that everyone is kind of forced to sit up and pay attention to what she’s been up to. Unless you’ve been living under a rock. A true blue katak di bawah tempurung. Then, and only then, can you probably escape the media blitzkrieg.
ANYWAY. So, when I first watched the Wrecking Ball video on Tumblr (I admit, I like being the first to see music videos from artists my friends like. I don’t have to like them – I just like being the first to say “HA I SAW THE VIDEO BEFORE YOU DID!” I am the only one who gets any pleasure out of this, everyone else like “So what?”. Rightly so), my thought process went kind of like this:
“Oh, super close up of Miley. Her eyes look like something out of Tron..”
“I wonder if that white cropped tank top is from American Apparel..”
“Damn she’s hot”
“Okay, sledgehammer”
“Giant wrecking ball”
“Oh no she’s starting to kiss the sledgehammer. No tongue, please Miley, keep your tongue in your mouth”
“Oh, wow, NAKED on the wrecking ball.. I hope it’s clean”
“AGH SHE DID IT SHE’S LICKING THE SLEDGEHAMMER”
“WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT”
And it was pretty much all like that the whole video through. Now, my first reaction was to tut tut at Miley and her seemingly downward spiral into prostitution. I’m not a prude, but I do consider myself relatively conservative when it comes to public nudity and stuff like that (although if you saw my Tumblr dashboard, you’d raise five eyebrows at me and call me a hypocrite but hear me out), so seeing Miley bare herself so shamelessly was a little shocking.
Then, I had to sit back and ask myself why I reacted to the video the way I did. It’s an emotional song, she’s singing about her very sudden break up with Handsome Face. Time and again, artists of all genres have chosen juxtapose their emotional vulnerability with physical vulnerability, so being naked made sense, in a way. For someone to admit that they will always want a particular person even after the relationship is done is a hard thing to do in solitary, how much more difficult must it have been to say it out loud where the person in question will be able to hear it?
I’m not saying that the video is amazing, revolutionary, a shining example to musicians everywhere of just how much you should bare to make people believe you are being vulnerable. It’s not. As a creative, I wouldn’t have chosen Terry Richardson (notorious for making models undress and photographing them in the nude even when they don’t really want to, and for having sex with his models while documenting it on camera – I mean, ew. Terry’s pretty gross) to direct the video. But in a way, if what Cyrus was going for was a complete dressing down of her controversial persona, this was definitely the way to go. Richardson’s style reminds me very much of a hospital – putting his subjects under the glaring light of a flash, so they have nothing to hide, including their nakedness – achieved that goal, assuming that’s that what it was.
Wrecking Ball as a song is good. It’s raw, it offers a lot of insight into what her relationship with Hemsworth was like, it is far more revealing of the artist than her naked body will ever be. It’s just that in our image-obsessed society, her body is what became the talking point of the video, which is meant to be an accompaniment to the song (but these days has become more than the song). Everybody, give Miley a break. At least she’s not turned into Lindsay Lohan, whose reputation is far more worrisome than a girl who seems to be really happy with what she’s doing with her life.